Skip to content
Real audit: 6 of 6 AI tools recommended a resort. On a booking question, 1 of 6 named it. See why
The audit The AI testing
The AI testing

Seven AI platforms, tested in depth

Every question runs on the seven platforms the audit scores. Microsoft Copilot joined the scored set in October 2026.

Illustrative data for a fictional inn. The question "Inn with a private dock in Portmarrow?" is asked three times on each of seven AI tools. ChatGPT mentioned the inn twice: mentioned. Claude never named it. Perplexity cited its site twice: cited. Gemini recommended it twice: recommended. Google AI Overviews named it once: not named. Google AI Mode mentioned it three times. Microsoft Copilot recommended it three times. Two of three tries decide each result.
Example: one question, seven AI tools, three tries each.
The platforms

Every question, on every platform, three times

ChatGPT Claude Perplexity Gemini Google AI Overviews Google AI Mode Microsoft Copilot

We read ChatGPT and Gemini the way a buyer sees them, on their public websites. Ongoing monitoring reads them the same way, so the two line up.

One buyer question in the center, asked three times on each of seven AI platforms: ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode and Microsoft Copilot. Every answer is saved.
At least 50

Unbranded questions per buyer type

Questions that never name you, built for each buyer type from intake.

With more than three buyer types, the first audit caps the total at 150 and rotates the rest into later retests.

5 voices

At least eight questions each

The researcher, the evaluator, the buyer, the defender doing due diligence, and the advocate who has already bought.

3 runs

Of every question, on every platform

One question on one platform, asked three times, is a pair. A result counts when it holds in two of the three tries.

At least 20

Brand questions, recorded

Questions that name you, across ten kinds of fact from your fact block. They are reported and never scored.

Why three? An AI answer is probabilistic. One answer is one sample, and it may not be the usual answer.

In testing, three asks on one day disagreed on naming the business in about 1 in 7 pairs, and in 1 in 3 where it was named at all.

Three tries show whether a result is settled (three of three) or contested (two of three). One try cannot.

Real data, names hidden. Share of runs where each AI tool offered a restaurant as an option on questions without its name, 213 runs per tool: Gemini 75.1 percent, Claude 57.7, Perplexity 44.1, Google AI Overviews 31.5 of 149 runs, Google AI Mode 30.5, ChatGPT 24.9. The same restaurant was known by name in 349 of 353 runs.
Real figures from a restaurant audit: the AI tools do not agree.
The questions

Questions written the way buyers type them

Buyers type short questions, so the audit asks short questions.

  • At least 35 percent of the unbranded questions are eight words or fewer.
  • The middle question runs six to twelve words, and none runs past twenty-two.
  • A question about a place names the place, because an AI tool cannot know where "near me" is.
  • Every word is checked against your site or your buyer's vocabulary.
Example, illustrative data for a fictional inn in the fictional harbor town of Portmarrow, one question in each of the five buyer voices. Researcher: "Best inns in Portmarrow." Evaluator: "Portmarrow inns with a private dock." Buyer: "Book a room in Portmarrow this weekend." Defender: "Do Portmarrow hotels charge resort fees?" Advocate: "What else does a Portmarrow harbor inn offer besides boat slips?"
The five voices, as they might read for a fictional inn in a fictional harbor town.

Competitive questions, written open

At least ten competitive questions leave room for you in the answer, such as "alternatives to Quayside Hotel in Portmarrow."

A question that fixes the answer to two named rivals is recorded and not counted for or against you.

How buyers ask, and how AI searches

Buyers also write long questions about their own situation. A separate set asks questions worded that way, and saves the web searches each AI tool runs to answer them.

In testing, the AI's searches ran about 8 words against 32 in the buyer's question. More than a third added a ranking word such as "best," and many added a year.

We run each of those searches on Google to see whether your business comes back. This set is recorded and compared with the scored set, never scored.

Branded and unbranded

Brand questions are kept apart from the score

The score asks one thing: does AI put you forward to a buyer who did not ask for you?

Unbranded questions never name your business and build the score: does AI put you forward unasked? Brand questions name your business, are each tied to a row of your fact block, and are recorded, never scored: does AI know your business? Read side by side, the two sets tell apart "AI does not know this business" and "AI knows it and does not put it forward."
Two sets of questions, two different answers.

Why brand questions stay out

A question that names you is easy to appear in. Counting it would inflate every rate.

Multi-part requests

At least twelve requests, each with three or more hard requirements, such as a date, a place and a facility you offer.

They record which requirements AI drops and who it names instead. Recorded, never scored.

Sampling, stated plainly

Three runs per question is below the published recommended minimum of seven to eight repetitions (Schulte et al., 2026).

Every document says so, and every stability figure is reported against the runs taken.

The result

How a result is classed: mentioned, cited, recommended

Every answer goes through the same four questions, in order, from a written and versioned rubric.

Question 1
Named?

Does the answer name you, by any way your name is written? If not, you are not in the answer.

Question 2
Offered?

Are you offered as an option, rather than used as a landmark or a comparison?

Question 3
For or against?

If the answer advises against you, it goes to the reputation review.

Question 4
Recorded

The answer is classed, with your position in any list and the sources it cited.

A reader's impression never assigns the result.

Not offered
Not in the answer

Not named, or named only as a landmark or a comparison.

Result 1
Mentioned

The answer offers your business as an option for the person asking.

Result 2
Cited

The answer links your own website at your mention. Decided by where the link sits, not by a reader.

Result 3
Recommended

The answer puts your business forward as a pick for the person asking. Not applied to brand questions.

Illustrative answer with fictional names. Asked: inn with a private dock in Portmarrow. The Copilot answer calls Harbor Light Inn the pick for its guest slips, names Quayside Hotel, and links harborlightinn.example. The four questions: named, yes, first of two; offered as an option, yes; for or against, for; own site linked at the mention, yes. Classed as cited and recommended.
Example: one answer, read with the four questions.
The checks

Every result is read twice before it counts

Three checks stand between a saved answer and a printed number.

A second reading

A different model reads every answer again and records its confidence. One agreement figure is printed in the documents.

Hand review

Where the two readings disagree on a line that changes a score, or confidence is low, the row is ruled by hand before scoring.

An outside AI reader

An AI from a different model family reads the summary and assessment cold. Every headline or material challenge is fixed or answered with a saved capture.

Illustrative data for the fictional Harbor Light Inn, 60 unbranded questions on each of seven AI tools. Mentioned, cited, recommended: ChatGPT 24, 6, 12; Claude 15, 2, 6; Perplexity 22, 11, 9; Gemini 18, 6, 8; Google AI Overviews 17, 8, 7; Google AI Mode 19, 7, 9; Microsoft Copilot 15, 1, 7. All seven, of 420 pairs: 130, 41, 58.
Example: the printed results, platform by platform.

Find out where you stand in AI answers, and what to fix first.

We can help you identify the gaps and put them in order, starting with the ones your team controls.